Month: January 2018

Almost €250m paid in Medical Negligence Claims during 2017

The State Claims Agency (SCA)  has revealed that a record figure of €248.88m was paid in medical negligence claims during 2017.

This figure is an increase of 20.6% on the amount paid out during 2016, €206.4m in total.

In the report released by the State Claims Agency, figures indicate that that the SCA has paid out €1.123bn since 2010 in relation to medical negligence compensation claims. The figures produced show that between clinical, and €32.87m in general claims awarded against the general health sector, the SCA has paid out €1.235bn in total in the last seven years.

These details were revealed to Fianna Fail Finance Spokesman Michael McGrath by the Minister for Finance Fine Gael TD Paschal Donohoe following a written request for the specific details of the figures paid out by the State in compensation claims.

There were also significant increases in compensation claims against other sectors since 2010 including:

  • €23.6m in personal injury claims awarded against the Defence Forces.
  • €19m out by the Irish Prison Service
  • €11m paid out the Child and Family Agency TUSLA since it was established in 2013
  • €111m paid out by state authorities since 2010.

The main finding of the report was that, by far, that largest portion of compensation pay outs by the SCA in 2017 was taken up by the public medical sector.

Another significant point to note from compensation claims made against the state in 2017 were as follows:

  • €1.38m was last year paid out by the SCA on behalf of Comprehensive and Community Schools with €296,673 paid out by the Dept of Health.
  • €261,569 was paid out by the Deptartment of Justice while €574,632 was paid out on behalf of Day Schools.
  • €196,090 was paid out by Childrens’ Detention Schools.

Playground Accident at Bettystown Caravan Park Results in €975,000 Settlement

A man, now aged 20, who was paralysed from the waist down after falling off a small child’s playground swing in a Bettystown. The judge, referring to the incident as a ‘silly act’ has approved a €975,000 personal injury settlement in relation to the accident.

Liam Daly (20) sustained suffered thea serious spine injury on July 24, 2013. when he fell and landed heavily on his back. Liam fell from the playground swing, designed for toddlers and young children, in the caravan park in Bettystown where the family’s mobile home was located.

John Daly, father of Liam Daly, Nephin Road, Dublin 7, took the compensation claim for the playground accident against Lynch’s Caravan Park, Bettystown.

Bruce Antoniotti SC, legal counsel for Mr Daly, told the court that the Daly family had been holidaying at the caravan park for 10 years with no incident prior to the accident occurring. It was claimed that the cradle seat of the swing rotated to the most extreme arc position and Liam was thrown in the air. Mr Antoiniotti stated that there was not enough done to prevent teenagers form using the swings. The Lynch’s denied these claims as and did not argued that there was contributory negligence as the plaintiff got on a swing which was designed for younger  and smaller children.

He sat on the cradle of the swing in question but, as he swung, he fell back and sustained a very serious spinal injury. Counsel for Mr Daly said that the protective cover on the ground was not ‘state of the art’ but accepted that this was irrelevant as it would not have restricted the injuries suffered by him.

He (Liam) is now wheelchair bound. Despite his injuries Mr Daly has learned to drive a car and is looking for job.

In approving the playground accident compensation settlement Mr Justice Cross Mr Daly was just aged 15 at the time of the accident and the injuries he suffered were the result of a ‘silly act’.