Month: March 2019

Store Room Accident Compensation Award of €24,000 for Shop Worker

A shop worker has been awarded in excess of €24,000 store room accident compensation against her employer after falling over the open flap of a clothes box in the store that she was working in.

Ms Smiths legal counsel, Barrister John Nolan appearing with Kent Carty Solicitors, told the Circuit Court that Ms Smith had damaged her shoulders and back in the accident that happened in the store during November 2015. His client said that the storeroom at the Vera Moda shop in the Pavilion Shopping Centre, Swords, had been over packed untidily with boxes. Ms Smith (28) said she had been moving stock from a store room when her knee hit off the flap of a box, causing her to suffer a big fall. She was inflicted with injuries to her neck and both shoulders and her back and had a soft tissue injury to her wrist after having made an attempt to break her fall with her hands.

Aisling Smith, of Woodlawn Way, Santry, Dublin 17 was informed by Circuit Court President Mr Justice Raymond Groarke that, due to contributory negligence, he was reducing her personal injury compensation award to just over €19,000 as she had not been maintaining an adequate look-out in the Vera Moda store.

Judge Groarke awarded Ms Smith a total of €22,500 store room compensation but cut the personal injury compensation award to €19,125 due to the aforementioned contributory negligence. He remarked that she had been employed at the store for a long enough period of time that should have seen to it that she was aware of the importance of keeping a proper look-out and been more careful in relation to her own safety.

He said that proof provided by consultant forensic engineer Barry Tennyson, who had completed an examination of the stock room, indicated that the defendant had put a big effort into tidying up the store before the joint engineering inspection. Judge Groarke said the stock room had been kept in a rather messy manner.

Ms Smith told the court that a stock box had been moved out from a safe position against the wall and was left with one of its flaps lying open and causing an obstruction. A store room accident compensation award of €2,000 for loss of earnings was incorporated into her final compensation award.

€52,600 Creche Accident Compensation Awarded For Thigh Bone Break

A nine-year-old boy who broke his leg in a creche accident in 2014 was awarded €52,600 creche accident compensation against its the owners of the childcare centre.

Legal representative for the boy’s family, Barrister Ronan Quinn told the court that Cillian Geraghty was with a group of children who were brought to the bathroom to use the facilities on September 17, 2013, just days in the aftermath of his fourth birthday.

Mr Quinn, who was representing for Ms Andrea Geraghty and her Cillian, was appearing in court along with Joe Clancy Solicitors and advised the court that Cillian broke a thigh bone after a fall and was restricted in his movement for a number of weeks. He had to stay home from school in a right hip spica cast. Andrea informed Circuit Court President Mr Justice Raymond Groarke that a light was switched off and on, without any warning, which startled Cillian and he fell in the bathroom at the creche.

Cillian was brought to Crumlin Hospital on the day of the accident for treatment. Medical staff at the children’s hospital chose to keep the boy in overnight before he underwent surgery the next day.

Mr Quinn told Judge Groarke that, following initial examinations and care, Dr Paula Kelly, consultant orthopaedic foot and ankle surgeon at the Beacon Consultants Clinic, Sandyford, Dublin, noted a 0.5mm length discrepancy between Cillian’s right leg and his left. However she said that this condition had resolved  itself when she reviewed in during later examinations.

Ms Geraghty informed the court, via an affidavit, that the Personal Injuries Assessment Board (PAIB) had said a creche accident compensation award of €32,000 would be standard for an injury such as the one Cillian suffered. However, she was not satisfied with this. Additional settlement negotiations were conducted between all parties involved and RSA Insurance, who were representing the creche. Following this a new compensation offer of €50,000.

Ms Gerathy told Judge Groarke that the family had also had to repay a sum of €2,000 to their private health insurers.

Judge Groarke, who said he was satisfied from Ms Geraghty’s assurances to the court that Cillian had returned to full health after the accident. He approved the creche accident compensation settlement terms of €52,600.