School Door Accident Compensation of €10,000 Awarded to Young Girl

A girl from Dublin, who suffered a slightly stunted finger injury after her hand was caught in in a door in her primary school, has been awarded school door accident compensation of €10,000 at Dublin District Court.

The second class pupil took the personal injury compensation action via her mother against Knockmore Junior School, located in Tallaght, in relation to the injuries she sustained in 2017.

The district court was informed that the young girl got her little finger caught in a doorway. In an attempt to settle the case an offer of €10,000 was made. In court medical reports and pictures of the hand injury were provided to Judge Michael Coghlan.

The judge was advised that medical reports indicated the girl’s hand was completely rehabilitated within three months. Her finger was slightly stunted, by 20pc, in comparison the same finger on her other hand,  and there was slight disfigurement in that finger. She experienced pain when getting nails cut had been an issue but this has not subsided in the intervening two and a half years, counsel said.

The judge asked that the girl be brought close to the judge so he could look at her hands. Judge Coghlan said that they were right to bring it to his attention. However, he was not happy it was a major injury deformity and not going to inflict embarrassment.

In relation to it looking different to the same finger on her other hand, he said, it was unlucky it happened. He said: “If you can find a person with identical hands you could put them in the Guinness Book of Records, no one has identical hands.”

Judge Coghlan gave his approval for a €10,000 school injury compensation award. He said that the money was to be paid into court funds on behalf of the girl until she comes of age.

He dismissed an application by her lawyer to make available €500 for immediate payment because her first holy communion was coming up. In addition to this he awarded €1,422 in special damages or expenses.